The best Nightfall: First Edition cards under $50 (2026)

The strongest Nightfall: First Edition cards you can buy for under $50 right now, ranked by real closed-sale prices — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does.

Also: under $20 · under $100

1. 1
   
   Nightfall First Edition Booster Box (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $35.61· $705 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
2. 2
   
   Nightfall First Edition Spoiler Pack (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $19.99· $49 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
3. 3
   
   Nightfall First Edition Spell Book (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $13.25· $34.99 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
4. 4
   
   Release Event Medal (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $3.99· $6 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
5. 5
   
   Nightfall First Edition Booster Pack (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $2.99· $10.5 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
6. 6
   
   Nightfall First Edition Blister Pack (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $2.75· $7.64 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
7. 7
   
   Thunderbird (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $0.99· $30 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
8. 8
   
   Wendigo (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $0.98· $38.68 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
9. 9
   
   Dark Watchers (Nightfall: First Edition)

   $0.91· $15 new/sealed
   eBay ↗Sold comps →
10. 10
    
    Smokey Spirits (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.83· $2 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
11. 11
    
    Flood The Earth (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.77· $30 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
12. 12
    
    Dampen (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.5· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
13. 13
    
    Headless Coal Miner (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.5· $25 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
14. 14
    
    Mothman (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.5· $125 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
15. 15
    
    Twin Meteor (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.5· $5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
16. 16
    
    Righteous Reckoning (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.49· $45 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
17. 17
    
    Guardian Angel (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.49· $32 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
18. 18
    
    Absorb Aura (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.45· $9 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
19. 19
    
    Sinister Shadows (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.43· $1.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
20. 20
    
    Ground (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.37· $0.54 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
21. 21
    
    Index (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.36· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
22. 22
    
    River Of Time (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.36· $30 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
23. 23
    
    Old Books Crying Tree (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.35· $12 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
24. 24
    
    Napa Rebobs (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.35· $8 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
25. 25
    
    Jack O Lantern Bomb (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.35· $0.94 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
26. 26
    
    Suburban (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.35· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
27. 27
    
    Banish (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.35· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
28. 28
    
    Wallowa Lake Crustacean (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.34· $7 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
29. 29
    
    Light Elemental (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.33· $5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
30. 30
    
    Bubbling Brew (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.31· $1.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
31. 31
    
    Indrid Cold (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.31· $12 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
32. 32
    
    Torrential River (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.31· $2.49 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
33. 33
    
    Vampire Mercy Brown (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.3· $2.49 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
34. 34
    
    Boogeyman (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.29· $12 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
35. 35
    
    Boil Over (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.27· $30 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
36. 36
    
    Swamp (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.27· $6.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
37. 37
    
    Adam Ackler (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $30 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
38. 38
    
    Full Moon (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $0.35 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
39. 39
    
    Winter (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
40. 40
    
    Mountain (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
41. 41
    
    Wood Devil of Coos Country (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $9.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
42. 42
    
    Copy Cup (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $0.5 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
43. 43
    
    Teakettler (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $1 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
44. 44
    
    Stalactites (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $25 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
45. 45
    
    Grim Reaper (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $120 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
46. 46
    
    Grafton Monster (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $15 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
47. 47
    
    Potion Seller (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $8 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
48. 48
    
    Hope Diamond (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $12 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
49. 49
    
    Prism Beam (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $30 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →
50. 50
    
    Destroy Terra (Nightfall: First Edition)

    $0.25· $0.99 new/sealed
    eBay ↗Sold comps →

Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.