The Most Valuable High Seas Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 375 tracked High Seas items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Diamond Amulet Treasure (High Seas) at $4,444.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
Diamond Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$4,444· $4,444 new/sealed - 2
Pearl Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$1,799· $1,799 new/sealed - 3
Sapphire Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$900· $1,000 new/sealed - 4
Pounamu Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$849.95· $999.69 new/sealed - 5
Opal Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$649.95· $699.99 new/sealed - 6
Amethyst Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$600· $699.89 new/sealed - 7
Onyx Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$574.98· $599.95 new/sealed - 8
Ruby Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$560.89· $999.89 new/sealed - 9
Platinum Amulet Treasure (High Seas)$398.99· $467.49 new/sealed - 10
High Seas Booster Box Case (High Seas)$370.48· $899.99 new/sealed - 11
Riches of Tropal Dhani (High Seas)$370.33· $599.99 new/sealed - 12
Gravy Bones Shipwrecked Looter Marvel (High Seas)$139.71· $249.95 new/sealed - 13
Dead Threads Treasure (High Seas)$127.31· $310.99 new/sealed - 14
Marlynn Treasure Hunter Marvel (High Seas)$114.25· $345 new/sealed - 15
Polly Cranka Treasure (High Seas)$98.38· $345.79 new/sealed - 16
High Seas Booster Box (High Seas)$95.45· $225 new/sealed - 17
Puffin Hightail Marvel (High Seas)$94.7· $178.99 new/sealed - 18
Gold Baited Hook Treasure (High Seas)$88.08· $129.99 new/sealed - 19
Conqueror of the High Seas Treasure (High Seas)$85.6· $249.99 new/sealed - 20
Sawbones Dock Hand (High Seas)$73.2· $123.5 new/sealed - 21
Portside Exchange Treasure (High Seas)$69.95· $112.36 new/sealed - 22
Gold Baited Hook (High Seas)$63.62· $129.99 new/sealed - 23
King Shark Harpoon Extended Art (High Seas)$62.91· $150 new/sealed - 24
Old Knocker Treasure (High Seas)$62.17· $71.5 new/sealed - 25
Chum Friendly First Mate Marvel (High Seas)$54.42· $125 new/sealed - 26
Palantir Aeronought Extended Art (High Seas)$51.19· $90 new/sealed - 27
Unicycle Treasure (High Seas)$48.77· $119.01 new/sealed - 28
King Kraken Harpoon Extended Art (High Seas)$47.84· $147.99 new/sealed - 29
Sunken Treasure Treasure (High Seas)$46.02· $74.99 new/sealed - 30
Goldfin Harpoon Treasure (High Seas)$44.77· $125 new/sealed - 31
Golden Tipple Blue Treasure (High Seas)$42.28· $124.86 new/sealed - 32
Sealace Sarong Treasure (High Seas)$41.61· $499.99 new/sealed - 33
Loan Shark Treasure (High Seas)$38.01· $61.94 new/sealed - 34
Give No Quarter Extended Art (High Seas)$37.09· $79.99 new/sealed - 35
Diamond Amulet (High Seas)$36.79· $59.99 new/sealed - 36
Gravy Bones Marvel (High Seas)$36.31· $108.99 new/sealed - 37
Anka Drag Under (High Seas)$33· $130.99 new/sealed - 38
Pounamu Amulet (High Seas)$32.94· $42 new/sealed - 39
Cogwerx Tinker Rings Treasure (High Seas)$32.87· $110 new/sealed - 40
Dead Threads (High Seas)$31.11· $199.99 new/sealed - 41
Tip the Barkeep Treasure (High Seas)$30.22· $67.18 new/sealed - 42
Wailer Humperdinck Marvel (High Seas)$29.63· $104.55 new/sealed - 43
Marlynn Marvel (High Seas)$27.87· $80 new/sealed - 44
Codex of Frailty (High Seas)$27.67· $70 new/sealed - 45
Puffin Marvel (High Seas)$27.5· $51.16 new/sealed - 46
Saltwater Swell Blue Treasure (High Seas)$27.23· $45 new/sealed - 47
Sea Floor Salvage Treasure (High Seas)$26.21· $49.99 new/sealed - 48
Saltwater Swell Red Treasure (High Seas)$25.51· $99.99 new/sealed - 49
Oysten Heart of Gold (High Seas)$21.22· $55.9 new/sealed - 50
Chum Friendly First Mate (High Seas)$20.9· $40 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.