The Most Valuable 1991 Pro Set Football Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 922 tracked 1991 Pro Set Football items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No Logo] #335 1991 Pro Set Football at $29.99.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
![Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No Logo] #335 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/barry-sanders-bo-jackson-no-logo-335-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No Logo] #335 1991 Pro Set Football$29.99· $149 new/sealed - 2
![Hobby Box [Series 2] 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/hobby-box-series-2-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
- 3
![Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No NFLPA Logo on Back] #335 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/barry-sanders-bo-jackson-no-nflpa-logo-on-back-335-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [No NFLPA Logo on Back] #335 1991 Pro Set Football$14.99· $88.27 new/sealed - 4
John Randle #835 1991 Pro Set Football$11.27· $200 new/sealed - 5
![Derrick Thomas [Error Bills Helmet on Front] #19 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/derrick-thomas-error-bills-helmet-on-front-19-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
Derrick Thomas [Error Bills Helmet on Front] #19 1991 Pro Set Football$8.39· $99.99 new/sealed - 6
- 7
Neil O'Donnell #845 1991 Pro Set Football$2.8· $144.38 new/sealed - 8
Tom Waddle #818 1991 Pro Set Football$2.74· $129.95 new/sealed - 9
- 10
![Warren Moon [Large Type on Back] #370 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/warren-moon-large-type-on-back-370-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
- 11
Brett Favre #762 1991 Pro Set Football$2.28· $150 new/sealed - 12
![Darion Conner [Drafted 1st Round '99] #92 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/darion-conner-drafted-1st-round-99-92-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
- 13
- 14
![Walter Payton [Team 34] #1 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/walter-payton-team-34-1-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
Walter Payton [Team 34] #1 1991 Pro Set Football$2.21· $119.45 new/sealed - 15
- 16
- 17
- 18
Erik Kramer #824 1991 Pro Set Football$2· $59.95 new/sealed - 19
![Jim Kelly [No NFLPA Logo] #78 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/jim-kelly-no-nflpa-logo-78-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
- 20
Red Grange #2 1991 Pro Set Football$1.99· $99.99 new/sealed - 21
- 22
![Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [NFLPA Logo on Back] #335 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/barry-sanders-bo-jackson-nflpa-logo-on-back-335-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson [NFLPA Logo on Back] #335 1991 Pro Set Football$1.99· $60.7 new/sealed - 23
- 24
- 25
- 26
- 27
- 28
Whitney Houston #350 1991 Pro Set Football$1.92· $87 new/sealed - 29
- 30
- 31
- 32
- 33
- 34
- 35
![Mike Croel [Rookie of the Year] #850 1991 Pro Set Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/mike-croel-rookie-of-the-year-850-football-cards-1991-pro-set-sport/thumb.webp)
- 36
- 37
- 38
- 39
- 40
- 41
- 42
- 43
Marcus Allen #541 1991 Pro Set Football$1.77· $7.7 new/sealed - 44
Erik Williams #799 1991 Pro Set Football$1.76· $33.7 new/sealed - 45
Lawrence Taylor #336 1991 Pro Set Football$1.76· $20.34 new/sealed - 46
- 47
Lawrence Taylor #394 1991 Pro Set Football$1.75· $29.92 new/sealed - 48
Judd Garrett #710 1991 Pro Set Football$1.75· $9.99 new/sealed - 49
- 50
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
More rankings
2024 Panini Prizm Football Cards2024 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2024 Topps Baseball Cards2023 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Topps Baseball Cards2021 Panini Prizm Football Cards2023 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2025 Topps Chrome Football Cards2024 Panini Select Football Cards2021 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2022 Topps Baseball CardsAll rankings →