The best 1989 Upper Deck Baseball cards under $50 (2026)
The strongest 1989 Upper Deck Baseball cards you can buy for under $50 right now, ranked by real closed-sale prices — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does.
Also: under $20 · under $100
- 1
![Mike Gallego [Reverse] #583 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/mike-gallego-reverse-583-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Mike Gallego [Reverse] #583 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$6.18· $99.99 new/sealed - 2
![Brian Holton [Error] #72 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/brian-holton-error-72-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
- 3
![Fred Manrique [Batting] #628 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/fred-manrique-batting-628-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Fred Manrique [Batting] #628 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$4.27· $4.27 new/sealed - 4
![Bill Schroeder [Ronn Reynolds] #627 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/bill-schroeder-ronn-reynolds-627-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
- 5
Checklist 1-26 #27 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.89· $152.51 new/sealed - 6
Mickey Brantley #550 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.71· $5 new/sealed - 7
Randy Johnson: Star Rookie #25 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.64· $230 new/sealed - 8
![Gary Varsho [Mike Bielecki] #321 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/gary-varsho-mike-bielecki-321-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Gary Varsho [Mike Bielecki] #321 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.61· $899 new/sealed - 9
- 10
![Gary Sheffield [Upside Down] #13 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/gary-sheffield-upside-down-13-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Gary Sheffield [Upside Down] #13 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.21· $500 new/sealed - 11
![Herm Winningham [Error] #636 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/herm-winningham-error-636-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Herm Winningham [Error] #636 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3.09· $32 new/sealed - 12
Nolan Ryan #774 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$3· $192.5 new/sealed - 13
Charlie Leibrandt #637 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.99· $36 new/sealed - 14
Marty Barrett #173 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.74· $23.5 new/sealed - 15
Billy Ripken #283 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.72· $84.2 new/sealed - 16
- 17
Mike Dunne #518 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.59· $71 new/sealed - 18
Mike Boddicker #542 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.54· $28.45 new/sealed - 19
Nelson Liriano #109 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.5· $25 new/sealed - 20
John Smoltz #17 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.49· $65.15 new/sealed - 21
- 22
![Fred Manrique [Throwing] #628 1989 Upper Deck Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/fred-manrique-throwing-628-baseball-cards-1989-upper-deck-sport/thumb.webp)
Fred Manrique [Throwing] #628 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.36· $22.99 new/sealed - 23
Bob Boone #119 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.31· $41.89 new/sealed - 24
Nolan Ryan #145 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.29· $138 new/sealed - 25
Mario Diaz #318 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.25· $26 new/sealed - 26
Bert Blyleven #712 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.24· $27.49 new/sealed - 27
Rob Thompson #172 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.24· $21.96 new/sealed - 28
Dante Bichette #24 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.2· $45 new/sealed - 29
Randy Bush #158 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.15· $14.99 new/sealed - 30
Storm Davis #153 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.14· $44 new/sealed - 31
John Shelby #75 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.14· $12.77 new/sealed - 32
Luis Salazar #136 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.09· $40 new/sealed - 33
Louie Meadows #401 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.09· $1.83 new/sealed - 34
- 35
Shane Mack #182 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.04· $34.99 new/sealed - 36
Mike Gallego #583 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2.04· $41 new/sealed - 37
Mike Campbell #337 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2· $26 new/sealed - 38
Scott Garrelts #50 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2· $60 new/sealed - 39
Todd Benzinger #184 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$2· $38.38 new/sealed - 40
Brian Holton #72 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.99· $250 new/sealed - 41
Greg Gagne #166 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.99· $5.5 new/sealed - 42
Gary Sheffield: Star Rookie #13 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.99· $39.99 new/sealed - 43
- 44
Craig Biggio #273 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.99· $49.83 new/sealed - 45
Jimmy Jones #286 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.97· $26.74 new/sealed - 46
Jim Presley #642 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.94· $40 new/sealed - 47
Larry McWilliams #143 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.92· $47.5 new/sealed - 48
Ozzie Canseco #756 1989 Upper Deck Baseball$1.92· $24.99 new/sealed - 49
- 50
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.