The Most Valuable 1986 Topps Football Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 404 tracked 1986 Topps Football items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Complete Set 1986 Topps Football at $146.84.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
- 2
Jerry Rice #161 1986 Topps Football$49.99· $72,500 new/sealed - 3
J.Montana, K.O'Brien #225 1986 Topps Football$23.48· $23.48 new/sealed - 4
Steve Young #374 1986 Topps Football$11.46· $3,118 new/sealed - 5
Reggie White #275 1986 Topps Football$8.49· $9,000 new/sealed - 6
William Perry #20 1986 Topps Football$4.55· $1,131 new/sealed - 7
Tony Hunter #81 1986 Topps Football$4.35· $36 new/sealed - 8
Bruce Smith #389 1986 Topps Football$4.19· $5,778 new/sealed - 9
Joe Montana #156 1986 Topps Football$3.99· $3,353 new/sealed - 10
Walter Payton #11 1986 Topps Football$3.89· $2,600 new/sealed - 11
Bernie Kosar #187 1986 Topps Football$3.77· $1,165 new/sealed - 12
Boomer Esiason #255 1986 Topps Football$3.72· $1,279 new/sealed - 13
Andre Reed #388 1986 Topps Football$3.19· $1,608 new/sealed - 14
Dan Marino #45 1986 Topps Football$3.13· $2,238 new/sealed - 15
John Elway #112 1986 Topps Football$3· $1,975 new/sealed - 16
![Passing Leaders [K.O'Brien, J.Montana] #225 1986 Topps Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/passing-leaders-k-o-brien-j-montana-225-football-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Passing Leaders [K.O'Brien, J.Montana] #225 1986 Topps Football$2.99· $37.51 new/sealed - 17
Jay Hilgenberg #17 1986 Topps Football$2.82· $187.44 new/sealed - 18
Wes Hopkins #279 1986 Topps Football$2.63· $59.99 new/sealed - 19
Wilber Marshall #25 1986 Topps Football$2.62· $492.96 new/sealed - 20
![Bears Team [Walter Payton] #9 1986 Topps Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/bears-team-walter-payton-9-football-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Bears Team [Walter Payton] #9 1986 Topps Football$2.32· $377.85 new/sealed - 21
![Bengals Team [Boomer Esiason] #254 1986 Topps Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/bengals-team-boomer-esiason-254-football-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Bengals Team [Boomer Esiason] #254 1986 Topps Football$2.09· $139.5 new/sealed - 22
![Bears [Payton In Motion] #9 1986 Topps Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/bears-payton-in-motion-9-football-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
- 23
Mickey Shuler #102 1986 Topps Football$2.03· $70.55 new/sealed - 24
Charles Mann #181 1986 Topps Football$2.02· $130.18 new/sealed - 25
Walter Payton #7 1986 Topps Football$2· $639 new/sealed - 26
Super Bowl XX #8 1986 Topps Football$1.99· $148.55 new/sealed - 27
Eric Dickerson #78 1986 Topps Football$1.99· $710.44 new/sealed - 28
Steve Largent #4 1986 Topps Football$1.99· $101.5 new/sealed - 29
Karl Mecklenburg #119 1986 Topps Football$1.99· $472.27 new/sealed - 30
Zeke Mowatt #145 1986 Topps Football$1.98· $106.87 new/sealed - 31
![Saints Team [Wayne Wilson] #338 1986 Topps Football](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/saints-team-wayne-wilson-338-football-cards-1986-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Saints Team [Wayne Wilson] #338 1986 Topps Football$1.95· $48.55 new/sealed - 32
Kevin Butler #18 1986 Topps Football$1.95· $252.41 new/sealed - 33
Dwayne Woodruff #290 1986 Topps Football$1.89· $44.92 new/sealed - 34
Art Still #311 1986 Topps Football$1.88· $769.88 new/sealed - 35
Al Toon #101 1986 Topps Football$1.87· $899.95 new/sealed - 36
Mark Clayton #49 1986 Topps Football$1.87· $132.5 new/sealed - 37
Jackie Slater #85 1986 Topps Football$1.87· $136.99 new/sealed - 38
Roger Craig #157 1986 Topps Football$1.87· $204.5 new/sealed - 39
Kenny Easley #211 1986 Topps Football$1.86· $131.23 new/sealed - 40
Tony Dorsett #126 1986 Topps Football$1.85· $134.16 new/sealed - 41
Vance Johnson #116 1986 Topps Football$1.82· $279 new/sealed - 42
Mike Lansford #86 1986 Topps Football$1.8· $225.25 new/sealed - 43
Frank Minnifield #198 1986 Topps Football$1.8· $252.85 new/sealed - 44
Mike Singletary #24 1986 Topps Football$1.8· $420.51 new/sealed - 45
Mike Rozier #351 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $202.5 new/sealed - 46
Curt Warner #202 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $130.72 new/sealed - 47
Joe Morris #139 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $149.95 new/sealed - 48
Steve Largent #203 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $812.5 new/sealed - 49
Otis Wilson #23 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $132.42 new/sealed - 50
Warren Moon #350 1986 Topps Football$1.79· $727.88 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.
More rankings
2024 Panini Prizm Football Cards2024 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2024 Topps Baseball Cards2023 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Panini Prizm Football Cards2025 Topps Baseball Cards2021 Panini Prizm Football Cards2023 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2025 Topps Chrome Football Cards2024 Panini Select Football Cards2021 Panini Prizm Basketball Cards2022 Topps Baseball CardsAll rankings →