The best 1959 Topps Baseball cards under $100 (2026)
The strongest 1959 Topps Baseball cards you can buy for under $100 right now, ranked by real closed-sale prices — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does.
- 1
Willie Mays #50 1959 Topps Baseball$95.55· $25,391 new/sealed - 2
Bob Clemente #478 1959 Topps Baseball$84.85· $22,713 new/sealed - 3
Sandy Koufax #163 1959 Topps Baseball$71.5· $13,611 new/sealed - 4
Willie Mays #563 1959 Topps Baseball$69.9· $13,709 new/sealed - 5
Hank Aaron #380 1959 Topps Baseball$67.94· $30,000 new/sealed - 6
Hank Aaron #561 1959 Topps Baseball$61.5· $12,094 new/sealed - 7
Mickey Mantle #461 1959 Topps Baseball$57.96· $10,211 new/sealed - 8
![Willie Mays [Baseball Thrills - Mays Catch Makes Series History] #464 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/willie-mays-baseball-thrills-mays-catch-makes-series-history-464-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Willie Mays [Baseball Thrills - Mays Catch Makes Series History] #464 1959 Topps Baseball$49.99· $3,650 new/sealed - 9
Ernie Banks #559 1959 Topps Baseball$46.91· $8,744 new/sealed - 10
Willie Mays #464 1959 Topps Baseball$44· $8,506 new/sealed - 11
Roger Maris #202 1959 Topps Baseball$43.57· $8,016 new/sealed - 12
![Roger Maris [White Back] #202 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/roger-maris-white-back-202-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Roger Maris [White Back] #202 1959 Topps Baseball$42.51· $8,691 new/sealed - 13
Yogi Berra #180 1959 Topps Baseball$40· $7,933 new/sealed - 14
Ernie Banks #350 1959 Topps Baseball$33.89· $6,985 new/sealed - 15
Harmon Killebrew #515 1959 Topps Baseball$33.8· $7,105 new/sealed - 16
![Roger Maris [Gray Back] #202 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/roger-maris-gray-back-202-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Roger Maris [Gray Back] #202 1959 Topps Baseball$30.74· $7,543 new/sealed - 17
![Ralph Lumenti [No Option Statement] #316 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/ralph-lumenti-no-option-statement-316-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Ralph Lumenti [No Option Statement] #316 1959 Topps Baseball$29.5· $6,193 new/sealed - 18
Norm Cash #509 1959 Topps Baseball$29· $5,616 new/sealed - 19
Stan Musial #150 1959 Topps Baseball$27.18· $12,900 new/sealed - 20
Fence Busters #212 1959 Topps Baseball$25.78· $3,981 new/sealed - 21
Yankees Team #510 1959 Topps Baseball$23.7· $4,157 new/sealed - 22
Roy Campanella #550 1959 Topps Baseball$23.49· $4,555 new/sealed - 23
Warren Spahn #40 1959 Topps Baseball$23.27· $4,492 new/sealed - 24
Hank Aaron Clubs World Series Homer #467 1959 Topps Baseball$22.1· $3,732 new/sealed - 25
![Dolan Nichols [No Option Statement] #362 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/dolan-nichols-no-option-statement-362-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Dolan Nichols [No Option Statement] #362 1959 Topps Baseball$21.86· $4,240 new/sealed - 26
Frank Robinson #435 1959 Topps Baseball$21.82· $4,662 new/sealed - 27
![Warren Spahn [Born in 1931] #40 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/warren-spahn-born-in-1931-40-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Warren Spahn [Born in 1931] #40 1959 Topps Baseball$21· $4,076 new/sealed - 28
![Fence Busters [Gray Back] #212 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/fence-busters-gray-back-212-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Fence Busters [Gray Back] #212 1959 Topps Baseball$20.23· $2,611 new/sealed - 29
![Haywood Sullivan [No Circle Copyright, U.S.A] #416 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/haywood-sullivan-no-circle-copyright-u-s-a-416-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Haywood Sullivan [No Circle Copyright, U.S.A] #416 1959 Topps Baseball$20.09· $3,496 new/sealed - 30
Al Kaline #360 1959 Topps Baseball$19.99· $8,418 new/sealed - 31
Bob Skinner / Bill Virdon / Roberto Clemente #543 1959 Topps Baseball$19.95· $4,443 new/sealed - 32
![Warren Spahn [Born in 1931-3 Obscured] #40 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/warren-spahn-born-in-1931-3-obscured-40-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Warren Spahn [Born in 1931-3 Obscured] #40 1959 Topps Baseball$19.39· $3,764 new/sealed - 33
Richie Ashburn / Willie Mays #317 1959 Topps Baseball$19.36· $3,784 new/sealed - 34
![Fence Busters [White Back] #212 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/fence-busters-white-back-212-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Fence Busters [White Back] #212 1959 Topps Baseball$18.77· $3,577 new/sealed - 35
Brooks Robinson #439 1959 Topps Baseball$17.75· $3,449 new/sealed - 36
Duke Snider #20 1959 Topps Baseball$17.65· $3,351 new/sealed - 37
Al Kaline #562 1959 Topps Baseball$17.33· $3,289 new/sealed - 38
Whitey Ford #430 1959 Topps Baseball$17.19· $3,663 new/sealed - 39
Mike Cueller #518 1959 Topps Baseball$16.31· $3,011 new/sealed - 40
Felipe Alou #102 1959 Topps Baseball$15· $3,012 new/sealed - 41
Ed Mathews #450 1959 Topps Baseball$13.91· $4,830 new/sealed - 42
Don Drysdale #387 1959 Topps Baseball$13.36· $5,400 new/sealed - 43
Kaline, Maxwell #34 1959 Topps Baseball$12.53· $2,089 new/sealed - 44
![Gil Hodges [White Back] #270 1959 Topps Baseball](/api/images/junkpal-products/sports/gil-hodges-white-back-270-baseball-cards-1959-topps-sport/thumb.webp)
Gil Hodges [White Back] #270 1959 Topps Baseball$11.97· $2,041 new/sealed - 45
Minnie Minoso #80 1959 Topps Baseball$11.88· $2,467 new/sealed - 46
Stan Musial #470 1959 Topps Baseball$11.65· $2,109 new/sealed - 47
Bill Mazeroski #555 1959 Topps Baseball$11.44· $2,270 new/sealed - 48
Warren Spahn #571 1959 Topps Baseball$11.06· $2,161 new/sealed - 49
Pirates Team #528 1959 Topps Baseball$10.75· $2,250 new/sealed - 50
Gil Hodges #270 1959 Topps Baseball$10.53· $2,074 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.