Beanie Babies resale values
1,814 Beanie Babies priced on real sold comps. See what each is worth — loose or complete — before you buy or sell.
Updated August 2026 · prices refresh as new sales close.
Matteo Beanie Baby
Issy Seattle Beanie Baby
Hark (green) Beanie Baby
Hello Kitty (Halloween bat 2014) Beanie Baby
Rubble Beanie Baby
Ears | 03/15/98 SGA | Oakland A's vs Anaheim Angels | MLB Baseball Beanie Baby
Ewey (frowning) Beanie Baby
Dimples (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Captain SpongeBob Beanie Baby
Niña (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Scooby Doo Vampire (black and red cape) (Walgreens Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Freckles (big eyes) Beanie Baby
Carl Edwards #99 Beanie Baby
Happy Birthday (yellow, NF New Face) Beanie Baby
Icecubes (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Jumpshot Beanie Baby
Flutter Beanie Baby
Kanata Nunavut (Canada Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Freezie Beanie Baby
Peace Beanie Baby
Baby Girl (2005) Beanie Baby
Baaabsy Beanie Baby
Issy Maui Beanie Baby
Rainbow Dash Key-Clip Beanie Baby
Eggs Beanie Baby
Matlock Beanie Baby
Leroy Key Clip Beanie Baby
Hamley (Hamleys Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Koowee Key-Clip (Australia, New Zealand Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Janglemouse Beanie Baby
Marsh (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Happy Holidays (Hallmark Exclusive) Beanie Baby
DAD-e (Ty Store Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Atlanta Braves Beanie Baby
Garfield (with DVD) Beanie Baby
Pico (2.0) Beanie Baby
Jinxed (BBOM Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Shasta (FTD Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Issy Paris Beanie Baby
Kiss-kiss (red) Beanie Baby
We Do Beanie Baby
Veggies Beanie Baby
Jeff Gordon #24 Beanie Baby
Fable (2.0) Beanie Baby
Lovely (with mouth) Beanie Baby
California (Knott's Berry Farm) Beanie Baby
Frankenteddy (purple and red feet) Beanie Baby
Danny Dog (UK Exclusive) Beanie Baby
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.