Nightmare worth
Answered from real closed-sale prices · updated August 29, 2026
5,352 priced items match — typical resale value $8.83 (range $0.08–$1,101)
✦ JunkPal AI
The Nightmare card's value depends heavily on its printing. The Magic Alpha version sold for $988.69 used, while the Beta version sold for $407.83 used. The International Edition sold for $15 used, and the Unlimited version sold for $8 used. For comparison, the 7th Edition Foil sold for $83.84 used, and the 4th Edition Alternate sold for $50.77 used. Currently, sellers are asking around a median of $26.95 for "Nightmare" on eBay.
![Nightmare [Foil]](/api/images/junkpal-products/cards/nightmare-foil-magic-7th-edition-card/img0/thumb.webp)
![Nightmare [Alternate]](/api/images/junkpal-products/cards/nightmare-alternate-magic-4th-edition-card/img0/thumb.webp)
Live on eBay right now — Nightmare
DISNEY NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS 22" CLOCK TOWER$197.67Buy ↗
nightmare before christmas 48 Piece Food Storage Container$20Buy ↗
NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS Figure Play Set DISNEY PVC TOY Jack OOGIE BOOGIE Zero$26.95Buy ↗
Bath & Body Works Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Sally Hands Pedestal HALLOWEEN$110Buy ↗
PRE-SALE YUGIOH x3 MAMO-EN122 NIGHTMARE-EYES RESTRICT - SECRET RARE 1st EDITION$2.88Buy ↗
Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington LED Tombstone Decor Disney$14Buy ↗People also ask
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.