Eerie #1 worth
Answered from real closed-sale prices · updated July 25, 2026
185 priced items match — typical resale value $10.28 (range $0.09–$750)
✦ JunkPal AI
The value of *Eerie #1* depends heavily on the year of publication. The 1965 issue is valued at $750 used, while the 1951 issue is valued at $262.51 used. The 1958 issue is valued at $153.5 used, and the 2012 issue is valued at $6.36 used.
Live on eBay right now — Eerie #1 (1965)
Eerie #1 1st Issue From Editors Of Creepy Warren Magazine 2nd Printing High Grad$1,100Buy ↗
Eerie #1 1st Issue Warren Magazine 2nd Printing Rare 1965 Lot1134$1,250Buy ↗
Eerie Magazine #5 September 1965 Frank Frazetta Cover Comic Book$49.99Buy ↗
Eerie #91 1st Moonshadow Ortiz 1978 Mayo ROOK 1:1:BEST Canadian VARIANT CGC 9.8$179Buy ↗
Eerie #123 Sanjulian Skeletons 1981 Haggarth Mist John Lennon 1:3:BEST CGC 9.8$199Buy ↗
Monster World Magaines 1964 #1 & 1965 #5 $37Buy ↗People also ask
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.