Captain America #51 price
Answered from real closed-sale prices · updated July 18, 2026
11 priced items match — typical resale value $3.36 (range $1.85–$960)
✦ JunkPal AI
The catalog shows several Captain America issues, with the most valuable being Captain America #51 (1945) at a used value of $960. Other issues have much lower values, such as Captain America #151 (1972) at $11.56 used, and several Newsstand editions valued under $8.
Live on eBay right now — Captain America #51 (1945)
CAPTAIN AMERICA COMICS #51 1945 Bondage Cover Human Torch Atomic Bomb story$2,640Buy ↗
Captain America Comics #51 - Timely Comics 1945 CGC 6.0 Human Torch story. Atomi$3,149Buy ↗
Captain America 51 CGC 6.5 1945 Atomic Bomb Story$3,300Buy ↗
1945 #51 Captain America 8.0 Timely Comics. CGC$2,500Buy ↗
Captain America Comics #55 - Timely Comics 1946 CGC .5 Human Torch backup story.$839Buy ↗
Timely Comics Captain America Comics #31 1943 "The Terror of the Green Mist!"$2,000Buy ↗People also ask
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.