Buffalo Nickel
Answered from real closed-sale prices · updated August 9, 2026
153 priced items match — typical resale value $19.99 (range $2–$2,701)
The listed Buffalo Nickels have varying values based on their year of issue, with the 1914 Buffalo Nickel being the most valuable at $24.68 used, and the 1923 Buffalo Nickel the least valuable at $9.07 used. The value of a Buffalo Nickel is heavily influenced by its year of issue, condition, and rarity. For example, the 1914 issue is more valuable due to its historical significance and lower mintage compared to later years. If you have a specific year in mind, you can refer to the listed values for that year.
People also ask
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.