The Most Valuable Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories" Cards
Ranked by real closed-sale prices across 242 tracked Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories" items — not guesses, not asking prices. Updated August 2026; the order shifts as the market does. Right now the crown belongs to Crimson Moons Fairy Tale Grimm Crown Prince of the Crimson Moon Secret Uber (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories") at $200.
On a budget: under $20 · under $50 · under $100
Top 10 by sold value used new / sealed
- 1
- 2
Masterpiece Pilgrim Memories Booster Box (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$175· $175 new/sealed - 3
Pure Heart Stone of the Six Sages Secret (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$112.5· $125 new/sealed - 4
Cheshire Cat The Pilgrinning in Wonderland Secret (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$110· $115.5 new/sealed - 5
Fleeting Moon Jewel Uber Rare (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$28· $50 new/sealed - 6
Dark Alice Rabbit Princess (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$14.99· $15.74 new/sealed - 7
Pure Heart Stone of the Six Sages Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$14.95· $21 new/sealed - 8
- 9
Mikage Reiya (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$10.94· $13.77 new/sealed - 10
Pure Heart Stone of the Six Sages (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$9.9· $10.5 new/sealed - 11
Girl of Chaos Uber Rare (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$8.33· $17 new/sealed - 12
Bad Apple Uber Rare (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$8· $8 new/sealed - 13
Defiled Scripture Uber Rare (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$7.99· $11.89 new/sealed - 14
- 15
Crimson Moons Battleground MP01 Buy a Box 03 (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$6.49· $5.36 new/sealed - 16
Crimson Moons Battleground MP01 Buy a Box 04 (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$6.15· $6.3 new/sealed - 17
Crimson Moons Battleground MP01 Buy a Box 02 (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$6.05· $7 new/sealed - 18
Magic Stone of Moon Shade (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$6.01· $6.01 new/sealed - 19
Guardian Beast of the Light Palace Uber Rare (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.95· $11.05 new/sealed - 20
The Opening of the Fairy Tale Secret (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.85· $75 new/sealed - 21
Cheshire Cat The Pilgrinning in Wonderland (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.49· $11 new/sealed - 22
Aslan Lumias Guardian Beast Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.25· $6 new/sealed - 23
Falltgold the Dragoon Bahamut the Dragon King (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.22· $5.25 new/sealed - 24
Crimson Girl in the Sky Little Red the True Fairy Tale (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5.13· $5.95 new/sealed - 25
- 26
Cheshire Cat the Grinning Remnant (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5· $5 new/sealed - 27
- 28
Crimson Moon (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$5· $5.78 new/sealed - 29
Crimson Moons Battleground MP01 Buy a Box 01 (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.95· $5.2 new/sealed - 30
Return of the Usurper (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.86· $10 new/sealed - 31
Apple Roulette Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.2· $6.99 new/sealed - 32
Geryon (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.2· $4.37 new/sealed - 33
Chevaleresses Tears (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.2· $4.41 new/sealed - 34
Pop Up Fairy Tale Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4.13· $5 new/sealed - 35
Neverend Fairy Tale Dragon (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4· $4 new/sealed - 36
Ayu Lunar Swordswoman Ayu Shaman Swordswoman (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$4· $6.25 new/sealed - 37
Reiya Fourth Daughter of the Mikage (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$3.55· $15 new/sealed - 38
Return of the Blood (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$3.49· $3.5 new/sealed - 39
Return of the Shaman (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$3.48· $5.9 new/sealed - 40
Resonance Guardian of Pandora Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$3.4· $7.34 new/sealed - 41
Guardian Beast of the Light Palace Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$3· $7.54 new/sealed - 42
Laurite Seven Luminaries Astrologian (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.99· $11.55 new/sealed - 43
Magic Stone of the Wolfs Night Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.95· $2.95 new/sealed - 44
The Dusk Girl Scarlet the Crimson Beast (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.71· $2.77 new/sealed - 45
Alices Friends in Wonderland (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.61· $15 new/sealed - 46
Heavenly Magic Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.57· $2.65 new/sealed - 47
Father Dagon Familiar of Cthulhu Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.55· $2.61 new/sealed - 48
Crimson Moon Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.51· $2.99 new/sealed - 49
Pandoras Relic Arsenal Full Art (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.45· $3.45 new/sealed - 50
Puss in Boots DArtagnan the Bayoneteer (Masterpiece "Pilgrim-Memories")$2.45· $8 new/sealed
Values are informational estimates from real sales data. JunkPal may earn a commission when you buy through eBay links, at no extra cost to you.